Source Seafood Sustainably: Catch at The Old Fish Market
IN WEYMOUTH, UK, THE TEAM AT CATCH AT THE OLD FISH MARKET IS METICULOUS ABOUT CATCHING, COOKING AND SERVING THE RIGHT FISH AT THE RIGHT MOMENT. WE SPOKE TO CHEF-PATRON BEN CHAMPKIN ABOUT HOW THEY TACKLE SOURCING SEAFOOD IN SUSTAINABLE WAYS.
At Weymouth Harbour in Dorset, Catch at The Old Fish Market offers a sea-to-table dining experience guided by fresh, local catch. As Chef-Patron Ben Champkin explains, the entire purpose of the restaurant is to support Weymouth’s fishing communities and celebrate the top-quality seafood landed daily, just steps from the kitchen.
The kitchen works closely with Weyfish, fishmongers who have in business here for 37 years and who work closely with the local fishing community. “Building those relationships with the fishermen over the years has taken a lot of trust,” says Ben. “The restaurant came along in 2001, when a second floor was put in above the fishmongers. Catch is essentially a fine dining restaurant designed solely to celebrate all of Weymouth's local, seasonal shellfish and seafood.”
Supporting local fishing communities
Between the two operations, Catch and Weyfish offer valuable employment opportunities for younger generations, supporting them in developing valuable skills. “That's what this business is about: bringing the next generation up and giving them a career path, whether that’s in a hospitality environment or in the fishmongers,” says Ben. “That's so important because there are no young people going into the commercial fishing trade now. The older generations need to pass their knowledge and traditional skills on to these younger fishermen to sustain the local fishing community and to keep Weymouth Harbour and this community alive.”
Ian Barrett, Director and fishmonger at Weyfish, points to this as the biggest challenge facing small-scale fishing right now. “A lot of our fishermen are getting old now. They have all the essential knowledge of how to fish sustainably: all the different methodologies and what to do at particular times of the year. We need to pass all of this on to younger generations. It's vital that we don't lose what we've gained over the last 50 years to industrial fishing.”
This doesn’t just include destructive methods like trawling or dredging. “Much more dangerous is the factory ships that suck up fish indiscriminately,” he continues. “There's so much bycatch, so much wastage that's just unnecessary. In contrast, local fishermen on smaller boats will use methods like rod-and-line to target individual species with no by-catch or wastage whatsoever.” If these methods aren’t carried on, something truly critical will have been lost.
The restaurant is deliberate about showcasing the hardworking people behind the catch. “We celebrate the fishermen directly, highlighting them to our audience with their names, their vessels and their boat registrations under every dish they’ve supplied. That way, we're being very clear — in black and white — about who we're celebrating, what we're doing here and the purpose of this business,” Ben explains.
“We celebrate the fishermen directly, highlighting [...] their names, their vessels and their boat registrations under every dish they’ve supplied. We're very clear about who we're celebrating, what we're doing here and the purpose of this business."
On the menu
So, what does sourcing local, responsibly caught fish look like in Weymouth? “Our menu is quite reactive; it's based on having a conversation with the fishmongers downstairs to talk about what's landing, what weather conditions are like, what we need to work with. That might mean a lot of fish coming in, or more of a shellfish-heavy week,” says Ben.
Weymouth accounts for 40% of the UK's rod-and-line-caught sea bass, so this is a regular feature on the menu. “Other species that we celebrate here include grey mullet, red mullet, Portland crab, lobster, cuttlefish and skate wing,” says Ben. “At this time of the year, Weymouth Bay prawns are coming in the door. We're also very lucky to be on the doorstep of some amazing Portland oysters, and we take cockles and clams from Poole Harbour.” Bivalves like these are a particular favourite. “Foods like oysters, cockles and clams are filter feeders, so they clean the ocean floor. They're putting goodness back into the ocean. They're one of the most sustainable seafoods that we use upstairs.”
“Cornish Bluefin Tuna is in season from August through till October-November time, and we've been lucky enough to take a Bluefin Tuna once a week over the past few months,” Ben continues. Today, after extreme overfishing that almost wiped out populations, catching Bluefin in the UK is strictly monitored, with a very limited number of licenses available. “One of our boats in Weymouth Harbour has one of those licenses,” he says, “so we were able to land a Cornish Bluefin Tuna in Weymouth Harbour recently, which was pretty special.”
All of this is contingent on availability, driven by both seasonality and legislation. “For example, there is a ban on fishing wild sea bass at certain times of the year, so the fishermen will look for another species,” says Ian. “Black bream is a good substitute and can be line-caught by the bass fishermen, and you also have the gilt-head sea bream: their skin crisps up in a similar manner to sea bass.”
Ian also points to the importance of guiding people away from the ‘Big Five’ most popular species (cod, salmon, hake, tuna and prawns) towards lesser-known options. “There are good alternatives to cod, for example. We're using a lot of gurnard at the moment, some line-caught pollock — just giving our customers more choices to make sure we continue to have fish for the future.”
Ben would love to see this approach to sourcing seafood evident in more kitchens. “Chefs should be talking more to their fish suppliers and understanding what they can be using. There are all sorts of different species available in the UK, we've just got to seek them out and understand what's in season. At Catch, we're utilising what's in British waters and focusing on what's being brought in on the dayboats. You can get dayboats in Lyme, in West Bay, you can get them in Poole Harbour — all along the coast.”
“Dayboat fishing essentially means the boat has gone in and out within the day, so it also means the fish is the freshest it can be,” adds Ian. “This is accessible to everyone; you just have to speak to your fishmonger or your fish supplier.”
“Chefs should be talking more to their fish suppliers and understanding what they can be using. There are all sorts of different species available in the UK, we've just got to seek them out and understand what's in season."
Conscious choices
There are certain types of seafood that Ben consciously avoids. “We don’t serve any salmon; we replace this with trout. We use a sustainable fish farm called Houghton Springs Farm in Blandford, in Dorset. We've all just got to be mindful that most farmed fish need wild fish to feed them, which is destroying seabeds and causing problems with other species in our oceans.”
The kitchen also steers clear of dredged scallops. “Dredging is when they drag a big metal bar or a chain across the sea floor. This destroys the seabed and it pulls up lots of by-catch. We only take hand-dived scallops; this means divers are going down to the seabed and picking them by hand. They're not utilising anything that's going to damage those ecosystems.”
Dry ageing
Dry ageing fish is a central part of how the kitchen manages its catch. “When there are storms in the tides and fishermen aren't able to go out in the dayboats, dry ageing allows us to hold fish for longer,” says Ben. “For example, today we have grey mullet that was landed yesterday, and this will see us through the restaurant services for the week.” Preserving quality in this way enables the team to maximise their use of every fish and avoid waste.
Importantly, this process also has a positive impact on flavour. “Dry ageing firms up the flesh and dries the skin out, so it allows us to get a really crispy skin, almost like glass. Because it also draws any excess moisture out, it also intensifies the flavour of the meat.” Dry ageing allows Ben and the rest of the team to create dishes that aren’t often seen on menus. “We use dry ageing to make trout pastrami, for example. Once we smoke the dry-aged trout, we end up with a really nice, almost like meat-like texture.”
Whole fish cooking
Working to use the whole fish doesn’t just avoid waste — it also sparks creativity, leading to a menu that can surprise and delight customers. The bread course, for example, serves homemade seaweed focaccia (made with foraged sea lettuce) with toasted crab head oil and elderberry vinegar, some of that dry-aged trout pastrami and a brandade made by salting and smoking seabass tails and trimmings, then poaching them in milk. “We're using the whole fish, and you can see how that comes together across the menu,” says Ben.
Similarly, the heads of the Portland lobster are used to make an oil. “This is what we rest the lobster in once it's been cooked,” says Ben, “and then we also use it to make a mayonnaise.” This mayonnaise is whizzed with tomato water to create a flavour-packed sauce that will accompany the lobster; finally, the dish is finished with pickled sweetcorn.
“Dry ageing firms up the flesh and dries the skin out, so it allows us to get a really crispy skin, almost like glass. Because it also draws any excess moisture out, it also intensifies the flavour of the meat.”
Food Made Good at Catch
Catch at The Old Fish Market completed their first Food Made Good assessment in late 2025, with a three-star result. “The purpose of us doing the certification with The SRA was to ensure that our practices are the best they can be,” says Ben. “Honestly, it was more work than I expected! There are over 200 questions and every answer needs evidence behind it, so start to finish it took us the best part of seven months. For a small team, that’s a lot of evenings at a laptop after service. But it was a great process that made us sit and think about the ethos and practices behind Catch.”
For Ben, the biggest surprise me was how comprehensive the evaluation was. “It made us look at our whole operation — above and beyond our sourcing standards. It asks you to look at how you treat your team, what you give back to the community and the health side of your menu. Debating with the team on their opinions on how we reach our end goals in terms of sustainability and our community was really beneficial and a great teaching exercise.”
He says the live scoring on the Food Made Good platform was helpful. “You can see where you stand as you work through it, and the preliminary report before final submission meant we could go back and fill the gaps rather than finding out at the end. When the Source Seafood Sustainably score came back at 98%, the highest in the world, we were all incredibly proud. It really highlights our complete commitment to the harbour and our fishing community.”
“The biggest change is that it showed us where the gaps were,” Ben continues. “Some areas were a work in progress, and some we were doing the work on but not recording it. We’ve tackled both. Those questions now come up as a matter of course when we choose a supplier or buy equipment, and we’ve got much better at measuring and reporting what we do. It’s given us a really strong base to build on. The small changes add up, too. Microfibre cloths have replaced blue roll; lids have replaced cling film; and with the solar panels and heat pump, we’re saving more than 10 tonnes of CO2 a year while spending less on consumables.”
“The team were ecstatic when the result came through, and they’ve owned it since,” he wraps up. “Front-of-house talk to guests about our ethos with real confidence, because they know it’s been independently checked.”
Learn more about Catch at the Old Fish Market on their website.
If you’re looking for further insights about sustainable sourcing, don't miss our 2026-27 global sustainability insights report, "Hospitality Rising: Global Challenges, Local Solutions”. Exploring the latest trends and influences shaping the sector, it’s packed with examples of smart sustainability initiatives from businesses of all shapes and sizes across the world. Download your copy here!
For more insights and stories from across our global network, follow us on Instagram and LinkedIn and sign up to our newsletter! Interested in how your own sustainability work measures up? Take our free Food For Thought quiz to find out.